By Thomson Reuters, Financial Post - April 4 2012
Canada’s finance minister said on Wednesday he would rather not tighten mortgage rules again to curb high
household debt and that banks themselves are taking on that job by becoming more strict with their lending
Jim Flaherty said he has seen signs of moderation in the Toronto condominium market and expects to see a
similar trend in Vancouver, one of the country’s hottest real estate markets.
“Part of that is based on what I’m being told by people who build condominiums, and also what I’m being told by
some of our banks about their standards becoming more stringent with respect to their loans for condominium
development,” Flaherty told reporters in Vancouver after making a speech there.
Flaherty said it was up to markets to “fix” the housing and debt problem, not the government.
“I’ve tightened up the mortgage insurance market three times … I really don’t want to do it again,” he said.
“And I’m glad that some of the banks – at least one of the bank executives yesterday indicated that he agreed that
actually the banks should exercise prudence and not rely on government to do it for them,” he said.
Bank of Nova Scotia Chief Executive Rick Waugh said on Tuesday that the simmering housing market gives
reason for caution, but that it’s up to the country’s banks, rather than the government, to manage the risks of their
massive mortgage portfolios.
Several other bank executives – Toronto-Dominion CEO Ed Clark in particular – have said they would welcome further government moves on mortgages.
The government and central bank have been warning Canadians of the dangers of taking on too much debt,
particularly through mortgages, at a time of historically low interest rates and high housing prices. The ratio of debt
to personal disposable income hit a record high last year and has moderated somewhat since then.
Despite some resemblance to the U.S. housing market prior to the crash, most economists expect a soft landing
Flaherty has tightened rules three times since 2008 in the mortgage insurance market but left them untouched in
the federal budget last week, to the surprise of many.
The budget did propose enhanced supervision of the federal housing agency that issues mortgage insurance.
Flaherty said the banking regulator, the Office of the Superintendent for Financial Institutions, was studying the
Post Your Comment: